INTRODUCTION TO ACCOUNTING STANDARDS

10 Detailed Case Studies with Complex MCQs

Chapter: Accounting Standards (AS) and Ind AS

Case Study 1: Implementation of AS 1 - Disclosure of Accounting Policies (Pg 1.14)

Background: Naman Industries Pvt. Ltd. operates in the manufacturing sector, producing industrial machinery and consumer electronics. In the financial year ending March 31, 2024, the Board of Directors faces the challenge of disclosing accounting policies under AS 1. Some members suggest limited disclosure to maintain competitive advantage, while others push for full transparency for the sake of stakeholder trust.

The company also acquired machinery worth ₹15,00,000 from foreign suppliers. Due to exchange rate fluctuations, the final cost increased by 15%. Naman Industries also took a loan of ₹10,00,000 at 8% interest, and the CFO is uncertain whether to capitalize the borrowing costs under AS 16 (Borrowing Costs) or expense them. Additionally, the company follows the FIFO method for inventory valuation but is considering switching to the Weighted Average Cost method.

Numerical Scenario: The company borrowed ₹10,00,000 at an 8% interest rate. Due to the installation of the machinery over six months, the total borrowing cost for the period is ₹40,000. The CFO is deciding whether to capitalize or expense this cost as per AS 16.

MCQ 1: What is the main purpose of AS 1?

A) To minimize tax liabilities.
B) To enhance transparency and comparability.
C) To reduce financial disclosure.
D) To comply with company law.

Answer: B) To enhance transparency and comparability.

Solution: AS 1 focuses on ensuring financial transparency and comparability by requiring full disclosure of significant accounting policies.
MCQ 2: How should Naman Industries report changes in inventory valuation methods under AS 1?

A) No disclosure is necessary.
B) The change must be disclosed and its effect on comparability explained.
C) The company should adjust past statements.
D) The company should defer the change to the next fiscal year.

Answer: B) The change must be disclosed and its effect on comparability explained.

Solution: Under AS 1, changes in accounting policies, such as inventory valuation methods, must be disclosed with explanations of their financial impact.
MCQ 3: Should the company capitalize borrowing costs as per AS 16?

A) Yes, because the borrowing costs are directly attributable to the acquisition of the machinery.
B) No, borrowing costs should always be expensed.
C) Only if the costs exceed ₹50,000.
D) Only if the interest rate is fixed.

Answer: A) Yes, because the borrowing costs are directly attributable to the acquisition of the machinery.

Solution: AS 16 requires that borrowing costs directly related to the acquisition of a qualifying asset, like machinery, be capitalized.
MCQ 4: How should the 15% exchange rate fluctuation be treated under AS 11?

A) Expense the entire increase.
B) Capitalize the increase as part of the asset cost.
C) Recognize it as a financial loss.
D) Adjust it against reserves.

Answer: B) Capitalize the increase as part of the asset cost.

Solution: AS 11 allows exchange rate differences to be capitalized when they relate to the acquisition of a qualifying asset.
MCQ 5: What could happen if Naman Industries fails to disclose a change in accounting policy?

A) The financial statements may become misleading.
B) The company could face penalties.
C) No action will be taken if the change is immaterial.
D) Stakeholders will not be affected.

Answer: A) The financial statements may become misleading.

Solution: AS 1 requires full disclosure of changes in accounting policies. Failure to disclose could lead to misleading financial statements, potentially affecting stakeholders' decisions.
Case Study 2: Foreign Exchange Fluctuations and Borrowing Costs (Pg 1.13)

Background: ABC Corporation is an Indian multinational engaged in exporting machinery and importing raw materials. In the financial year ending March 31, 2024, the company experienced extreme foreign exchange fluctuations that significantly affected its liabilities. As per AS 11, the company must account for these changes appropriately in its financial statements. The company also borrowed funds in foreign currency, raising questions about how to capitalize or expense borrowing costs under AS 16.

Numerical Scenario: ABC Corporation took a foreign currency loan of ₹25,00,000 at a 9% interest rate for three years. Due to exchange rate fluctuations, the liability increased by 12%. The company also received a government grant of ₹8,00,000 for R&D, with 70% of the grant utilized during the financial year.

MCQ 1: How should foreign exchange fluctuations be treated under AS 11?

A) Capitalize the differences on foreign currency loans.
B) Recognize the differences in the income statement.
C) Adjust the differences in equity.
D) Defer the recognition until repayment.

Answer: B) Recognize the differences in the income statement.

Solution: AS 11 mandates that foreign exchange differences be recognized in the income statement, except under specific qualifying asset circumstances where capitalization is allowed.
MCQ 2: When should borrowing costs be capitalized under AS 16?

A) When they relate to a fixed asset.
B) When they are directly attributable to the acquisition or construction of a qualifying asset.
C) Borrowing costs should always be expensed.
D) Only for long-term projects.

Answer: B) When they are directly attributable to the acquisition or construction of a qualifying asset.

Solution: Borrowing costs should be capitalized when they are directly related to the acquisition or construction of a qualifying asset, as per AS 16.
MCQ 3: How should the government grant for R&D be treated under AS 12?

A) Recognize the entire grant as income in the same year.
B) Recognize the grant as deferred income and amortize it.
C) The grant should be recognized only when fully utilized.
D) Use it to reduce the cost of related assets.

Answer: B) Recognize the grant as deferred income and amortize it.

Solution: AS 12 requires government grants for specific purposes, like R&D, to be recognized as deferred income and matched with related costs over multiple periods.
MCQ 4: How should the 12% increase in liabilities from foreign exchange fluctuations be treated under AS 11?

A) Adjust the liabilities in the income statement.
B) Defer recognition until the loan is repaid.
C) Capitalize the increase.
D) Recognize the increase in equity.

Answer: A) Adjust the liabilities in the income statement.

Solution: AS 11 requires that foreign exchange fluctuations affecting liabilities be adjusted in the income statement for the relevant period.
MCQ 5: What should be done with the unutilized portion of the government grant?

A) Recognize the unutilized portion as income.
B) Defer recognition until the grant is fully utilized.
C) Use it to offset future expenses.
D) Write it off as a liability.

Answer: B) Defer recognition until the grant is fully utilized.

Solution: AS 12 requires that unutilized portions of government grants be deferred until the grant is fully utilized.
Case Study 3: AS 7 - Construction Contracts and AS 9 - Revenue Recognition (Pg 1.12)

Background: DEF Construction Ltd. is engaged in large-scale construction contracts, some of which span several years. The company needs to recognize revenue as per AS 7 (Construction Contracts) and AS 9 (Revenue Recognition). During the financial year ending March 31, 2024, DEF Construction completed 60% of a multi-year contract, with total revenue projected at ₹1,00,00,000.

Numerical Scenario: DEF Construction recognized ₹60,00,000 in revenue for the contract, based on 60% completion. However, due to unforeseen delays, the project incurred additional costs amounting to ₹15,00,000. The company also received an advance of ₹10,00,000 from another contract but has not yet started work.

MCQ 1: How should revenue be recognized under AS 7 for the completed 60% of the contract?

A) Recognize full revenue of ₹1,00,00,000.
B) Recognize ₹60,00,000 in revenue, proportional to the contract's completion.
C) Defer revenue recognition until the contract is complete.
D) Recognize only the advance received.

Answer: B) Recognize ₹60,00,000 in revenue, proportional to the contract's completion.

Solution: AS 7 requires revenue to be recognized in proportion to the contract's completion stage, hence 60% of the total contract value.
MCQ 2: How should the advance of ₹10,00,000 be treated under AS 9?

A) Recognize it as revenue.
B) Treat it as a liability until the work is started.
C) Defer it until work is completed.
D) Offset it against future expenses.

Answer: B) Treat it as a liability until the work is started.

Solution: AS 9 requires that advances be treated as liabilities until the related service or work begins.
MCQ 3: How should the additional cost of ₹15,00,000 be recognized under AS 7?

A) Capitalize the cost as part of the project.
B) Expense the cost immediately.
C) Adjust it in the next financial year.
D) Include it in the cost-to-complete estimate.

Answer: D) Include it in the cost-to-complete estimate.

Solution: AS 7 requires that any additional costs incurred during the construction be included in the cost-to-complete estimates.
MCQ 4: How should DEF Construction treat the revenue for future periods?

A) Recognize revenue in the current period.
B) Defer revenue recognition until work is completed.
C) Recognize revenue proportionally as the project progresses.
D) Recognize revenue only upon receipt of payment.

Answer: C) Recognize revenue proportionally as the project progresses.

Solution: AS 7 requires that revenue be recognized in line with the stage of completion of the contract.
MCQ 5: How should the advance received for another contract be disclosed in the financial statements?

A) Disclose it as a receivable.
B) Recognize it as revenue.
C) Show it as a liability.
D) Ignore the advance until work starts.

Answer: C) Show it as a liability.

Solution: AS 9 mandates that advances be shown as liabilities until work is performed or goods are delivered.
Case Study 4: Application of AS 2 - Valuation of Inventories (Pg 1.10)

Background: GHI Ltd., a manufacturing company, has faced difficulties in managing inventory costs due to fluctuating raw material prices. The company uses the FIFO (First-In-First-Out) method to value its inventories but is considering switching to the Weighted Average Cost method due to the volatility in prices. This decision requires adherence to AS 2 (Valuation of Inventories) to ensure the proper recognition, measurement, and presentation of inventory costs.

Numerical Scenario: GHI Ltd. has ₹5,00,000 worth of raw materials in inventory, purchased at varying prices over the financial year. With the shift to the Weighted Average Cost method, the company calculates that the new average cost would be ₹4,80,000, slightly lower than the original cost. This change could affect the company’s financial reporting, and management must carefully consider how to implement and disclose this switch in accounting policy.

MCQ 1: What is the primary objective of AS 2?

A) To determine the tax liabilities.
B) To provide consistent methods for valuing inventories.
C) To allow for flexibility in inventory valuation.
D) To minimize costs associated with inventory.

Answer: B) To provide consistent methods for valuing inventories.

Solution: AS 2 ensures that companies follow a consistent method for inventory valuation, ensuring that financial statements are comparable across periods.
MCQ 2: If GHI Ltd. switches to the Weighted Average Cost method, what should they do according to AS 2?

A) Switch without disclosing the change.
B) Disclose the change and its financial impact.
C) Defer the change until the next financial year.
D) Apply both methods simultaneously.

Answer: B) Disclose the change and its financial impact.

Solution: AS 2 requires full disclosure of any changes in the method of inventory valuation, along with an explanation of the financial impact.
MCQ 3: How should the difference between the FIFO and Weighted Average Cost be accounted for?

A) Adjust the financial statements retroactively.
B) Include the difference in the income statement.
C) Ignore the difference if immaterial.
D) Defer recognition until next year.

Answer: B) Include the difference in the income statement.

Solution: Any changes resulting from a switch in inventory valuation methods should be recognized in the income statement for the period in which the change occurs.
MCQ 4: If the change results in a lower inventory value, how should this affect financial reporting?

A) The lower value should be reported as a loss.
B) The lower value should be treated as a normal adjustment.
C) Defer the reporting of the lower value.
D) No adjustment is necessary if the difference is small.

Answer: B) The lower value should be treated as a normal adjustment.

Solution: A change in inventory valuation resulting in a lower value should be treated as a normal adjustment to inventory and reported in the current financial statements.
MCQ 5: What should GHI Ltd. do if the new method results in a material change in inventory values?

A) Adjust financial statements for prior periods.
B) Defer the change until the next fiscal year.
C) Disclose the impact and continue with the change.
D) Switch back to FIFO immediately.

Answer: C) Disclose the impact and continue with the change.

Solution: If the change in inventory valuation results in a material change, the company should disclose the impact but proceed with the new method in future periods.
Case Study 5: Borrowing Costs and the Treatment of AS 16 (Pg 1.22)

Background: JKL Ltd., a technology company, invested in constructing a new factory to expand its production capabilities. The company borrowed ₹50,00,000 at an interest rate of 10% per annum to finance the project. The construction took two years to complete, and the total borrowing cost for the period amounted to ₹10,00,000. JKL Ltd. needs to determine whether to capitalize or expense these costs as per AS 16 (Borrowing Costs).

Numerical Scenario: The construction of the factory qualifies as a "qualifying asset" under AS 16, and JKL Ltd. has incurred ₹10,00,000 in borrowing costs over the two-year period. The management is debating whether to capitalize the entire amount or expense it in the income statement.

MCQ 1: What is a qualifying asset under AS 16?

A) An asset that generates revenue immediately.
B) An asset that takes a substantial period to get ready for use.
C) Any fixed asset.
D) An asset that can be sold for profit.

Answer: B) An asset that takes a substantial period to get ready for use.

Solution: A qualifying asset is defined under AS 16 as an asset that requires a substantial period of time to get ready for its intended use or sale.
MCQ 2: How should JKL Ltd. treat the borrowing costs incurred during the construction period?

A) Expense them in the year incurred.
B) Capitalize them as part of the cost of the qualifying asset.
C) Amortize them over 10 years.
D) Include them in the income statement as a deferred expense.

Answer: B) Capitalize them as part of the cost of the qualifying asset.

Solution: AS 16 requires borrowing costs directly attributable to the construction of a qualifying asset to be capitalized as part of the asset's cost.
MCQ 3: What is the treatment of borrowing costs once the asset is ready for use?

A) Continue to capitalize borrowing costs.
B) Start expensing borrowing costs.
C) Defer recognition of borrowing costs.
D) Recognize borrowing costs as revenue.

Answer: B) Start expensing borrowing costs.

Solution: Once the qualifying asset is ready for its intended use, borrowing costs should no longer be capitalized and should be expensed in the income statement.
MCQ 4: How should JKL Ltd. disclose borrowing costs in its financial statements?

A) Include them as part of fixed asset costs.
B) Disclose them separately in the notes.
C) Include them under current liabilities.
D) Include them in reserves.

Answer: B) Disclose them separately in the notes.

Solution: Borrowing costs should be disclosed in the notes to financial statements, providing details about the amount capitalized and the treatment applied.
MCQ 5: If the project is delayed and borrowing costs increase, how should JKL Ltd. treat the additional costs?

A) Capitalize the additional costs.
B) Expense the additional costs.
C) Defer the additional costs.
D) Include the additional costs in future periods.

Answer: A) Capitalize the additional costs.

Solution: AS 16 requires any additional borrowing costs incurred during the extended period of construction to be capitalized as part of the qualifying asset.

Download
Chat on WhatsApp